Featured Post

Upcoming Changes to the Blog

I had no internet for the entirety of yesterday. As someone who is terminally online, this caused no small amount of distress. However, it d...

19 November, 2026

Let's Play (015) - Batnum '67: The Yellow Game

Release Date: 23rd of January, 1967

Platform: PDP-10

Genre: Strategy

Developer(s): John G. Kemeny

Publisher(s): DECUS


Moving through the years rather quickly now - we're now onto 1967! The year of Sgt. Peppers, plus the album debuts of Hendrix, Pink Floyd, and many others.

For video games... well, it's less good. With Batnum, we're starting with a very, very quick game. I shouldn't need to explain this too much, as Batnum, a portmanteau of "battle of numbers" is the most base form of Nim, the object removal game I played back in 1951 with Nimrod.

Likely the most notable thing about this earliest-known version of Batnum is that, up until two years ago, this was another lost game. It was recovered by a MyAbandonWare user named Benedict. According to the notes he provides with the program, he "found it in a book." Fortunately, he also provides a scan of the source code from this unknown book.

Benedict's source.

While this scan provides a date of completion for the game, it does not provide an author. I can only speculate on who authored this game. Said speculations lead me to believe that the creator of BASIC himself, John Kemeny, created this game. Reason being is that there is a different Batnum game included in David Ahl's 101 BASIC Computer Games, where Ahl cites Kemeny as having created that version, and for having created the original adaptation. Whether Ahl means that the Batnum in his book is the original adaptation, or if this earlier Batnum is, I cannot say.

David Ahl's take.

The program provided for which to run Batnum through features a rather garish yellow terminal interface. It appears that this may intended to replicate the yellowish teletype printer paper used way back in the day. Getting Batnum itself to run is quite simple - all you need to do is:

  1. Type "OLD"
  2. When asked what program to load, type "BATNUM.BAS"
  3. Press enter
  4. Type "RUN"

And the game will run. The first scenario the game presents you is the same each time you load the game - a pile of 79 objects, with the option to removed between 1 and 6 objects each turn. All subsequent games will be randomised. The game doesn't actually tell you the pile size until you've made your first move, which seems like a bit of an oversight. You'd think the player would like to know what they're working with before the game starts... (what's even more odd is that, when I played this in 2024, it did tell me what the starting number was. No idea what's changed since then - I haven't reinstalled the game.)

The opening scenario. Same every time you run the game.

In the long run, it doesn't really matter. Outside of the first game, the computer plays perfectly, meaning it's functionally impossible to win. The computer appears to be specifically programmed on the first game - and only the first - to play imperfectly, which does allow the player to win, provided you know what you're doing.

Battle of Numbers functions on what's called "modulo" arithmetic. In the simplest terms I can explain it, it's an n + 1 formula, where the most optimal play is to remove as many objects as would equal one more than the maximum allowed when both your own and your opponent's moves are added together.

A win, just for proof.

For example, if the maximum number of objects that could be removed was 6, and the computer took 3 on its turn, my best move would be to take 4, which adds up to 7 - one more than the maximum. There's a bit more to it than that, but providing a sufficient explanation is well above my paygrade.

Of course, the computer knows this as well, and the game is designed with it being in the advantaged position of going second. The player going second will always win if they play perfectly.

Random game being generated. Still not telling me the size of the pile.

For some reason, I recall being able to win once or twice in the randomised games when I played this originally in 2024. I've never been able to replicate that success since, so I question whether I'm misremembering what happened.


Scores

Time Played: 10 minutes

Difficulty: 9 (Punishing)
Technically, it's winnable - but only on the first round. Outside of that, it's impossible. Though I swear I beat it in the randomised rounds at least once in the past...

Gameplay: 1
I can't give this a zero - as much as I'd like to - seeing as there is an actual game here. It's the most banal, base form of gameplay imaginable, not helped by the ruthless computer and need to understand advanced mathematics to have a chance at winning.

Controls: 5
Completely and utterly standard.

Sound: N/A

Visual: 1
The formatting's clear, at least. Nothing beyond the basics, though.

Story: N/A

Functionality: 5
I've never seen the game bug out. Free points.

Accessibility: 2
On the surface, Batnum seems simple enough to play and understand. But, being a text game, and requiring its own proprietary download to play knocks it down a few pegs.

Fun Factor: 0
Constantly losing to a perfect AI is not fun. I could always be stupid in this case, not knowing exactly how the logic works. Mind you, if I have to learn some advanced mathematical algorithms to have even a chance of success at a game, it's not a good game.

Overall: 14/80 (17.5 | F tier)
Unsurprisingly, Batnum doesn't make a good showing in the scoring department. A weighted score of 17.5 places it at the top of the bottom - the F tier. I make no bones about not liking this game - I hated it when I first played it in 2024, and I still don't like it. There's nothing here than Nimrod doesn't do better; more flexibility in gameplay options, variable rules, plus you can actually win. That's last one's especially nice.

Video:


I've tried a different style for this video. It's more of an all-in-one casual review, since I never want to have to play Batnum again.


Up Next: PDP 10 Timesharing Basketball

No comments:

Post a Comment